Automatic vs Manual: What’s the Difference When It Comes to Car Hire?

One of the first choices you’ll need to make around car hire is whether to go for a manual or an automatic vehicle. While both options have their pros and cons, they offer very different driving experiences, and your choice can affect everything from fuel consumption to hire costs.

If you’re unsure which type of rental car suits you best, this guide breaks down the key differences between manual and automatic vehicles and what to consider before booking.

What’s the Difference Between Automatic and Manual Cars?

In a manual car, you change gears yourself using a clutch pedal and gearstick. With automatics, the vehicle shifts gears for you, so there’s no clutch and no gear changes to worry about.

This simple mechanical difference can have a big impact on how the vehicle drives, and which option is best for your journey.

Benefits of Hiring a Manual Car

• Lower hire cost – In the UK, manual car hire is often cheaper than hiring an automatic, simply because there are more manual vehicles available.
• More control – Some drivers prefer the hands-on feel of driving a manual car, especially on hilly or rural routes.

• Wider availability – Manual cars are still the norm in the UK, so you’re likely to find more choice when booking.

Benefits of Hiring an Automatic Car

• Easier to drive – Automatics are ideal for city driving or long journeys, removing the need to constantly shift gears in traffic.
• Better for beginners or international drivers – If you’re not familiar with UK roads or not confident driving a manual, automatics can feel more relaxed.

• Smoother experience – Especially in newer models, automatics offer a smooth, stress-free drive, particularly in stop-start conditions.

Manual and Automatic Car Hire Cost Difference

In general, automatic car rental tends to be slightly more expensive than manual. That’s because automatics are often newer models, and there are fewer of them in UK car hire fleets.

If you’re flexible on your choice, manual cars may offer better value. But for those prioritising convenience, comfort, or who only have an automatic licence, the higher price can be worth it.

Fuel Consumption: Does It Differ?

Fuel economy used to be one of the main reasons drivers opted for manual cars. However, many modern automatic vehicles are now just as efficient, especially with the introduction of hybrid and electric models.

That said, if you’re hiring an older car or prioritising cost per mile, a manual may still offer better fuel economy in some cases.

Which One Should You Choose?

When choosing between a manual or automatic hire car, think about:

• Your comfort and confidence behind the wheel
• The type of roads you’ll be driving on
• How much time you’ll spend in traffic
• Whether you’re looking for the best price or maximum ease

Whether you’re booking for a business trip, a holiday, or simply need a short-term solution while your own car is off the road, choosing the right transmission is key to a smooth and stress-free car rental experience.

Need help choosing the right vehicle?

Get in touch with our team today, regardless of if you prefer the ease of an automatic or the familiarity of a manual, we’ll help you find the perfect hire car for your needs. Call us on 0345 222 1022 or email info@psdvehiclerental.co.uk.